ICC Evaluation Criteria

on .

Item

Evaluation Criteria

Max. Marks

(a) 
Weighted

(b) 
Marks
(Max. 10)

(a)x(b) 
Weighted Marks 

1.0

Introduction (50 Marks)

1.1

Department background, groups, and group selection are described

20

2

   

1.2

Group proves the participation and effectiveness of project planning

30

3

   

2.0

Project Selection and Definition (150 Marks)

2.1

The group describes clearly how and why the project was chosen

80

8

   

2.2

The project is explained clearly.  Technical terms used must be explained.

40

4

   

2.3

Project target setting is explained and justified based on appropriate analysis or data/benchmarking information

30

3

   

3.0

Analysis Of Improvisation Opportunities (250 Marks)

3.1

Improvisation opportunities have been identified based on sufficient data/information that has been gathered through various ways and appropriate tools

80

8

   

3.2

Systematic analysis and evaluation of potential causes is made to verify the reasons with the use of appropriate tools

120

12

   

3.3

Verification and validation of improvisation opportunities/reasons that are made using a variety of methods

50

5

   

4.0

Solution/ Creative & Innovative Implementation  (200 Marks)

4.1

Group has identified a range of potential action/creative and innovative  solutions

50

5

   

4.2

Group evaluates each alternative solution carefully based on the final selection according to  appropriate criteria (advantages and disadvantages are taken into account)

70

7

   

4.3

Group has assessed the final  creative and innovative solution to the targeted objective

30

3

   

4.4

Group has been made and implemented creative and innovative  solutions successfully (difficulties/obstacles or how they were addressed, explained)

50

5

   

5.0

Monitoring and Standardisation (100 Marks)

5.1

Group has made sufficient and systematic monitoring to ensure that improvements are made in the order and maintained

50

5

   

5.2

Group seeks to make improvements to ensure that improvements are made in the order

20

2

   

5.3

Steps have been taken to ensure that the new procedures  supported, adopted, documented and shared

20

2

   

5.4

Actions have been taken to ensure that the new procedures adopted are standardised and maintained

10

1

   

6.0

Achievement & Value Creation (200 Marks)

6.1

An overview of the types and quantum of achievement and value creation

70

7

   

6.2

A reconciliation of actual performance targets have been made (unexpected cost explained)

30

3

   

6.3

The selection of the solution have been identified in accordance with the uniqueness of the company/industry/national and international

40

4

   

6.4

The effects of performance and creation of value to the environment, the community and the members of the group are set out

30

3

   

6.5

Group provides proof of verification and  performance validation and creation of value

30

3

   

7.0

Project Presentation (50 Marks)

7.1

Need performance, logical order and abide by the time allotted

30

3

   

7.2

Clear presentation,  effective use of audio-visual tools and good public speaking

20

2

   

Total

1000

100